news & announcements

Op-Ed: Why Texas should ban plastic bags

July 20, 2018

Houston Chronicle Op-Ed
By Rosanne Barone, Texas Campaign for the Environment

Photo: Rich Pedroncelli, STF / Associated Press

There’s no question. Plastic pollution is a serious problem.

For decades, advocates have been alerting us to the floating gyres of trash out at sea and here on Galveston’s shores, where sea turtles ingest plastic bits and plastic bags clog their digestive tracts. These days you can’t go long without seeing the next viral photo of some horrifying intertwinement of animal and plastic debris posted alongside the countless solutions proposed to address the problem.

Consumers have long been encouraged to reduce, reuse and recycle their plastic. Recently, we’ve begun to hear about companies taking responsibility for the problem, too. Starbucks claims they will phase out plastic straws by 2020 and restaurants all over the world, including in Houston, are experimenting with alternatives to single-use plastics.

But when should government step in? And can government even do so in a state like Texas?

This question has come to a head in the last few weeks. A Texas Supreme Court decision found in late June that the City of Laredo’s ordinance to restrict plastic bags was invalid under Texas law, as are 10 similar ordinances in cities across Texas. Even so, Supreme Court Justices Eva Guzman and Debra Lehrmann in a concurring opinion emphasized that not just protectors of marine life, but business owners like fishermen, boaters, cattle ranchers and cotton ginners know that plastic bag pollution is a big enough problem for lawmakers to start taking seriously.

It’s easy to see how we got here. Chemists spent several decades at the beginning of the 20th century experimenting with the newly discovered polyethylene, a chemical component produced from natural gas and oil. In the 1950s, Swedish chemists discovered a stronger and more flexible plastic (HDPE) and patented the first manufactured thin-film plastic bag.

As soon as Mobil Chemical (now ExxonMobil) got wind of this invention, they obtained dozens of production patents, suppressing competition and producing their own bags by 1977. They quickly swept up the major grocery chains, and their customers, as lifelong partners.

But the proliferation of plastic bag use impacted a whole lot more than just the company’s bottom line. It changed our way of thinking to accept that using an item for a total of 12 minutes — the average time of a bag’s use — and then disposing of it is somehow OK.

This culture opened the floodgates for a whole lineage of single-use disposable plastics, and now it’s nearly impossible to avoid the plastic packaging that’s covering almost everything we want to buy.

Years later, the increasing production and disposal rates of plastic have created a pollution problem so deadly, it was even recently compared to smoking by Stylist magazine — harmful, addictive, and being sold to us by billion-dollar industries and advertisers.

International movements like Break Free From Plastic are connecting the dots along plastic’s supply chain and highlighting how plastic harms at every stage in the process. Plastic production pollutes the air we breathe, too, during refining processes where the chemical building blocks of plastic are made from fossil fuels. Families surrounded by the refineries in east Houston are far too familiar with this scenario, where they’re constantly exposed to toxic emissions and experience higher rates of cancer, reproductive problems, immune disorders and respiratory and skin infections.

Meanwhile, the Gulf Coast is set to lead the nation in petrochemical expansion in the next few years.

What we might not have realized before, but is so clear now, is that there is a limit to how much excessive, unnecessary production we can handle, and the Earth is telling us loudly that we’ve reached it.

And that brings us back to Laredo’s case at the Texas Supreme Court. Elimination of the source of the problem is the right move. That’s what these bans are all about. They work because they reduce use, and therefore waste and pollution, significantly and immediately.

Retailers, especially those headquartered here in Houston like Randall’s, can stop giving out plastic bags right now even without an ordinance in place. As our Supreme Court justices recommended, the Texas legislature should act now to allow local government to address causes of plastic bag pollution. A bill like House Bill 3482 from 2017’s legislative session would do just that, and while we’re gearing up for elections, we can tell candidates running to represent us in Austin that we want them to support legislation like it.

Let’s stop holding on so tightly to plastic bags. We’re better without them, and there’s no time like the present to act.

Rosanne Barone is the Houston Program Director at Texas Campaign for the Environment, a statewide environmental advocacy organization.

Tags: , ,

Categories: News Clipping

See All Posts >

subscribe to get updates via email

Sign Up