Greater Houston

Big Green Bins and Justice for All

 

Today, more Americans recycle than vote. Thanks to overwhelming public demand, including thousands of personalized letters written by TCE supporters, Houston City Council voted in September 2014 to expand curbside recycling to everyone with city trash service![1] Despite budget challenges, they voted unanimously because recycling is not only a powerful way to protect the environment, it also creates thousands of jobs in our region.

Unfortunately, the "One Bin for All" proposal currently under consideration by City Hall would waste all the progress that has been made. Under this misguided plan, valuable resources which could be collected and sold would instead be contaminated with garbage, buried in ever-growing landfills or even incinerated, costing Houston jobs and creating more pollution. This plan is unsustainable and short-sighted.

Tell the Mayor and City Council:
Big Green Bins, Yes. "One Bin," NO!

Download Presentation from Video


Combining Trash and Recycling Wastes Resources

Very soon, City officials are proposing to invest tax dollars in a long-term contract with what is known as a "dirty MRF" (Materials Recovery Facility, pronounced "murf"), a $100+ million facility to supposedly separate out recyclables from garbage.[2] The City would tell residents to throw all their garbage and recycling into "One Bin for All." This is a huge step in the wrong direction.

What the City proposes is not "single-stream" recycling where residents can throw all of their glass, plastic, aluminum, paper, cardboard, etc. into the big, green bin while throwing their trash into the garbage bin. While single-stream is a proven and effective recycling technology, mixing garbage in with recyclables is simply a bad idea.[3] Throwing food and other messy wastes on paper, cardboard and other recyclables makes those materials less valuable in the marketplace. Other cities have attempted to build facilities, or dirty MRFs, to let machines sort out the garbage, but all have had very low recycling rates and have relied on incineration as a means to divert trash from landfills.

"One Bin For All" FAQs

Open Letter: SXSW Eco 2013 Panelists Urge Houston Mayor and City Council to Abandon "One Bin for All"

Incineration and Injustice

City officials say that there will be no "combustion" associated with this facility, but the proposal calls for "gasification" and "catalytic conversion."[4] [5] These technologies have been called "incinerators in disguise" by international waste reduction advocates,[6] and are defined as incineration by the US EPA.[7] They have been responsible for major pollution problems in communities that have tried them. The last thing Houston needs is to turn our trash into air pollution!

The real secret to dirty MRf facilities has been low wage labor. Workers with little to no job security have to pick through hazardous waste,[8] are exposed to dangerous conditions, terrible smells and other harms.[9] The City has also suggested that the facility be located at an existing waste disposal site, all of which are in predominantly working income communities of color. Concentrating all of the City's waste collection in one site poses significant local problems in terms of smell, noise, congestion, vehicle emissions and litter. The City's dirty MRF scheme will threaten the air, water, land, health and safety of Houston residents across the city.

Tell City Council: We Want Environmental Justice in Houston! Don't burn our future!

Click Here to Download the RFP Documents

Incineration is always the Wrong Choice

Incinerating waste, including gasification and catalytic conversion schemes, produces dioxins, furans and other Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs) which cause birth defects, hormonal disruptions and cancer. Incineration also competes with recycling for materials, which means we recycle less and extract more and more raw materials. Incineration eliminates incentives towards waste reduction and reuse, and is almost always much more expensive than reduction and recycling. Finally, recycling saves 3-5 times the energy that incineration produces. "One Bin for All" is a scheme to bring waste incineration to Houston. Take Action Now!

Read the Sierra Club Houston Regional Group's Resolution Against the Dirty MRF

Open Letter: Industry Experts Urge Houston to Abandon Dirty MRF

The Solution: Zero Waste

No single technology or facility can solve Houston's waste and recycling challenges. Communities and businesses around the world have adopted "Zero Waste" policies that combine waste reduction, product redesign, recycling, and composting to divert materials away from landfills, abolish trash incineration, create jobs and protect the environment. Our goal is to divert 90% of waste from landfills and incinerators. Several US cities have already reached 70% or 80%--so can Houston!

Open Letter: Zero Waste Advocates Urge Houston to Abandon Dirty MRF

Learn more about the Zero Waste Houston Coalition!

Universal Recycling

The first step is for the City of Houston to extend real curbside recycling to every home in the city. Houston's Solid Waste Management Department (SWMD) currently provides big, green recycling bins that accept paper, plastics, aluminum and glass to more than 200,000 homes with over 100,000 still on the waiting list.[10]

Other Texas cities with Zero Waste plans have passed Universal Recycling Ordinances that ensure recycling is available for apartment complexes, businesses and public spaces.[11] Zero Waste means recycling will be easy at home, work and play.

Listen to "Protesters Demand City Abandon 'One Bin for All' Recycling" on KUHF 88.7

Job Creation and Economic Development

Zero Waste isn't just good for the environment; it is powerful for the economy. Throwing away 10,000 tons of trash creates one job at a landfill, but would create 10 jobs in recycling and up to 296 jobs in material reuse![12]

Dallas and Austin have already passed Zero Waste plans, San Antonio has passed a "Pathway to Zero Waste" plan and Fort Worth is currently considering their own long-term plan to reduce waste. Now is time for Houston to move forward and develop a real strategy for conserving our resources.

Tell your elected officials today: we want Zero Waste and real recycling, not failed schemes like "One Bin for All."

 

If you don't have curbside recycling and are looking for a way to recycle at home, please see this list of recycling centers near you.

[1] See Houston Chronicle, "City to reach all homes with curbside recycling," September 15, 2014.

[2] See Houston Business Journal, "City of Houston seeking companies to work on One Bin for All project," June 2013.

[3] See Royal Society of Chemistry, Overview of Waste Management Options: Their Efficacy and Acceptability.

[4] See Off the Kuff, "City Response on One Bin for All," March 25, 213.

[5] See City of Houston, Request for Qualification Q24644.

[6] See Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives (GAIA), "Incinerators in Disguise."

[7] See Code of Federal Regulations, Title 40 - Protection of Environment.

[8] See Capitol Public Finance Group, LLC, Lessons Learned Operating a Mixed Waste MRF in Placer County, California.

[9] See Pellow, David N., Garbage Wars: The Struggle for Environmental Justice in Chicago, Cambridge: The MIT Press, 2002. p.155.

[10] See City of Houston Solid Waste Management Department, "Recycling" accessed Dec. 13, 2013.

[11] See City of Austin Resource Recovery, Universal Recycling Ordinance (URO).

[12] See Institute for Local Self Reliance, "Recycling Means Business".